Southeast Asia is a compelling region for entrepreneurs, with Malaysia and Indonesia being top contenders for those looking to get in on the ground floor of rapidly growing economies. On the one hand, Malaysia boasts modern infrastructure and a robust economy, favouring sectors like manufacturing and digital technology. On the other, Indonesia’s vast archipelago and colossal consumer base present lucrative opportunities for trade and service industries.
As with any country, the choice between Malaysia and Indonesia for business ventures hinges on various factors including the economic landscape, political stability, and ease of doing business. This article aims to provide a comprehensive analysis of these key factors, assisting prospective investors in making an informed decision. Based on our own research and on-the-ground experience in both markets, we will explore the opportunities and challenges in both nations, guiding you towards a decision aligned with your business aspirations and long-term growth objectives.
Economic Overview
Gross Domestic Product (GDP)
Malaysia, with a GDP of US$430.9 billion and a higher per capita income of US$13,000 (2023), indicates a more affluent consumer base compared to Indonesia’s larger GDP of US$1.42 trillion but lower per capita income of US$5,100. Malaysia’s real growth rate of 4% signifies a stable and growing economy, potentially offering a more predictable market for entrepreneurs.
Industry Sectors
Malaysia’s economy leans more towards services and high-tech industries, with services contributing 53.6%, and industry at 37.6% of the GDP (2017). Notable sectors include electronics, petroleum and natural gas, and pharmaceuticals, which are sectors with high-value additions and potentially higher profit margins.
On the other hand, Indonesia has a balanced economic structure but with a significant portion in lower-value addition sectors like agriculture, which constitutes 13.7% of its GDP (2017).
Trade and Investment
Malaysia has a vibrant trade sector, with exports amounting to US$333 billion and imports at US$246 billion (2021), hinting at a well-established international trade framework. The diversified export portfolio including high-tech products like integrated circuits and semiconductors, and strong trade relations with global partners like Singapore and the United States, can offer businesses an extended market reach and better supply chain integration.
Indonesia also exhibits a substantial trade sector with exports and imports to $US248 billion and US$194 billion respectively in 2021. Similar to Malaysia, it has strong trade relations with global partners like China, the United States, and Japan. While Malaysia’s export portfolio is more diversified with high-tech products, Indonesia excels in the export of commodities like Coal Briquettes and Palm Oil, which while profitable for now, are not forward-thinking in terms of the the new green economy.
Summary
While both Malaysia and Indonesia present unique business prospects, Malaysia’s more developed market and higher value-add industries could be seen as more favourable for entrepreneurs looking to start a business in a stable and potentially more predictable economic environment.
Malaysia vs Indonesia: Political Stability and Ease of Doing Business
Ease of Doing Business
Ranked 12th globally in ease of doing business, Malaysia exemplifies a business-friendly environment with streamlined regulatory procedures. The high ranking reflects a conducive atmosphere for entrepreneurs, characterised by lower bureaucratic hurdles and a more predictable business regulatory environment.
On the other hand, Indonesia, ranked 73rd, presents more bureaucratic challenges for entrepreneurs. The ranking indicates a more complex regulatory framework, requiring a more intricate navigation through the processes of starting and operating a business.
Political Stability
With a political stability score of 73/100, Malaysia provides a relatively stable political environment. This stability often translates to a consistent policy framework and a predictable legal environment, which are beneficial for long-term business planning and investments.
Indonesia, scoring 63/100, exhibits moderate political stability. The score reflects a level of uncertainty in the political landscape, which could lead to less predictability in policy implementation, potentially affecting the ease of conducting business in the country.
Summary
The comparative ease of navigating regulatory procedures and the more stable political landscape in Malaysia provide a conducive environment for entrepreneurs. This stability often translates to predictable policy frameworks, making Malaysia a relatively more favourable choice for starting a business. On the other hand, the bureaucratic hurdles and less predictable political environment in Indonesia could pose challenges for business operations.
Malaysia vs Indonesia: Infrastructure Development
Infrastructure is crucial for business operations, affecting logistics, accessibility to markets, and operational costs.
Air and Sea Ports
Malaysia hosts the Kuala Lumpur International Airport (KLIA), one of Southeast Asia’s busiest airports, facilitating global business and cargo movement. Moreover, its strategic location along the Straits of Malacca and modern port facilities like Port Klang and the Port of Tanjung Pelepas bolster maritime trade.
In contrast, Indonesia, despite having the busiest airport in Southeast Asia in 2017, Soekarno-Hatta International Airport, faces challenges with port infrastructure. The lack of a deep-water port necessitates transhipment through neighbouring countries, increasing shipping costs and time.
Road Networks and Industrial Parks
Malaysia’s well-developed highway network and modern industrial parks reduce transportation time and costs, providing ready-to-move-in business facilities.
Indonesia, with its vast geography, faces challenges in road network development and has fewer ready-to-move-in industrial parks, which might pose logistical challenges for businesses.
Summary
Malaysia’s robust infrastructure, strategic location, and modern industrial parks provide a conducive environment for business operations, giving it an edge over Indonesia, where infrastructural challenges could lead to higher operational costs and logistical hurdles.
Malaysia vs Indonesia: Pro-Business Policies
Despite trailing behind Indonesia in foreign direct investment (FDI), with Indonesia drawing $20.1 billion compared to Malaysia’s $11.6 billion in 2021, Malaysia is making notable strides to enhance its business-friendly environment. The recent investment of $6 billion by Amazon Web Services (AWS) has been hailed as a significant milestone, reflecting a vote of confidence from international investors.
Malaysia’s pro-business stance is further demonstrated through active government engagements to attract foreign investment. Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim, dubbed as Malaysia’s “top salesman,” has been pivotal in fostering a conducive business environment. His international engagements have been key in promoting Malaysia as a viable investment destination.
On the other hand, Indonesia’s higher FDI is driven by its vast market, natural resources, and initiatives like the Job Creation Act to ease business operations. Additionally, the establishment of a new Ministry of Investment in 2021 highlights Indonesia’s resolve to streamline bureaucratic processes for foreign investors.
Summary
The choice between Malaysia and Indonesia may come down to an investor’s priority. Indonesia’s higher FDI figures depict a strong market potential driven by a vast consumer base and natural resources. However, Malaysia’s commendable ease of doing business ranking, political stability, and targeted government initiatives to attract foreign investment create a favourable business ecosystem. Each country has its merits, and the decision could hinge on whether total FDI or a conducive business environment is the investor’s focal concern.
Malaysia vs Indonesia: Skilled Workforce
Malaysia takes pride in its educated workforce, with a significant emphasis on tertiary education as a pillar for life success. About 74% of Malaysians believe that possessing a tertiary degree is essential for achieving success in life. This underscores a culture deeply rooted in education, which inevitably cultivates a skilled workforce adept in various industry sectors.
On the other hand, Indonesia has a larger workforce due to its higher population. However, the skill level may vary widely, and the language barrier could pose a challenge as Bahasa Indonesia is the primary language used in the business environment. Although efforts are being made to improve the education system and English proficiency, the large pool of labour may still need substantial training to meet the standards expected by international companies.
Summary
The emphasis on education and the consequent skilled workforce in Malaysia could offer a significant advantage to entrepreneurs, providing a ready pool of qualified individuals for various industry sectors.
Although Indonesia has a larger workforce, the varying skill levels and the language barrier may pose challenges, necessitating additional training and resources. The choice between the two could hinge on the specific needs of a business, with those prioritising skilled labour likely finding Malaysia a more favourable environment.
Malaysia vs Indonesia: Strong Economic Growth and Diversified Economy
Malaysia’s economic blueprint for 2024 illustrates a commitment to bolstering its financial standing by cutting subsidies and taxing luxury goods. Offering various incentives, grants, and funding schemes to businesses, and with agencies like the Malaysia Investment Development Authority (MIDA) guiding foreign investors, Malaysia exhibits a structured approach towards nurturing economic growth and diversification. Its trade sector is further diversified with high-tech exports.
On the other hand, Indonesia, with a substantial trade sector and strong global trade relations, primarily exports commodities like Coal Briquettes and Palm Oil which show little signs of diversification. The contrast in export portfolios underscores Malaysia’s more advanced and diversified economy, potentially rendering it a more secure investment hub.
Summary
Malaysia’s broader economic diversification, structured support from government agencies, and clear economic blueprint portray a more organised and potentially secure opportunity for investors compared to Indonesia’s less diversified and commodity-dependent economy.
Where to Next with InCorp
Between the thriving landscapes of Malaysia and Indonesia, Malaysia notably stands out for its modern infrastructure, political stability, and conducive business environment fostered by pro-business policies. With an emphasis on education, it boasts a skilled workforce ready to propel your business to new heights. The diversified economy and strategic global trade relations further enhance its appeal for budding and established entrepreneurs alike.
While Malaysia emerges as a promising land for business ventures, navigating its terrain requires a trusted partner. With many opportunities awaiting in Malaysia’s burgeoning business ecosystem, aligning with a knowledgeable ally is crucial. InCorp, with its deep-rooted expertise, is ready to guide you through every step, ensuring a smooth transition into Malaysia’s business sphere. Reach out to InCorp today, and take the first step towards harnessing Malaysia’s potential for your business success.
FAQs on Malaysia vs. Indonesia
- Malaysia, ranked 12th globally, showcases better ease of doing business than Indonesia, ranked 73rd.
- Malaysia has a robust services sector and high-tech industries including electronics, petroleum, and pharmaceuticals.
- With modern ports, well-developed road networks, and ready-to-move-in industrial parks, Malaysia offers a conducive environment for businesses.
- Malaysia scores higher in political stability, providing a more predictable policy and legal environment for businesses.
Start your business in Malaysia today.
About the Author
