Two jurisdictions dominate Asia expansion conversations, and choosing between them will define your regional operations for years. Singapore holds the #1 position in the 2024 IMD World Competitiveness Ranking. China sits at 14th, down four places from the previous year. Those rankings favour Singapore on paper, yet they miss something significant: China’s 943 million urban consumers and unmatched manufacturing depth.
So, which jurisdiction suits your business? That depends entirely on your needs. A company seeking a regional headquarters faces different calculations than one chasing market share or supply chain integration. This article examines incorporation timelines, tax structures, IP protection, labour costs, and logistics – the factors that will actually shape your decision.
Key Takeaways
- Choose Singapore for rapid 1-2 day incorporation and 100% foreign ownership, or navigate China’s 2-4 week registration process to access its massive domestic market of 943 million urban consumers.
- Leverage Singapore’s tax-friendly environment featuring 0% capital gains and dividend withholding tax, compared to China’s higher baseline rates which require navigating complex incentives for relief.
- Rely on Singapore’s top-ranked IP regime and international arbitration standards for robust protection, while approaching China with a defensive “first-to-file” trademark strategy.
- Weigh Singapore’s higher operating costs and specialized talent shortages against China’s abundant junior workforce and more tenant-favorable office rental market.
- Use Singapore as a premier global transhipment hub with superior customs efficiency, or tap into China’s unmatched manufacturing depth despite its slower processing speeds.
Company Formation: Days Versus Weeks
The gap in incorporation timelines reveals deeper differences in how each jurisdiction treats foreign businesses. In our experience, Singapore’s digitised system allows company registration in 1 to 2 days. Foreign investors can hold 100% ownership without local partners. The single requirement: at least one locally resident director, a role corporate service firms like InCorp routinely fill during setup.
China demands more patience. We find that registration typically takes 2 to 4 weeks, with complexity built into the process from day one. Every company must declare a fixed “Business Scope” – the specific activities permitted, printed directly on the business licence.
Operating outside this scope blocks your ability to issue official invoices (fapiao), which effectively freezes revenue collection. Foreign shareholders must also commit registered capital sufficient to cover at least one year of operations, including rent and salaries.
For businesses prioritising speed and flexibility, Singapore wins decisively. For those committed to China’s domestic market, the administrative investment is simply part of the entry cost. Neither approach is wrong – they reflect fundamentally different regulatory philosophies.
Related Read: From Idea to Incorporation: Forming a Singapore Private Limited Company
Tax Structures and Profit Repatriation
The headline tax rates tell a straightforward story. Singapore charges 17% corporate income tax. China charges 25%. That 8-percentage-point gap widens considerably when you factor in capital gains and dividend treatment.
Singapore imposes no capital gains tax – a significant advantage for investment holding companies and venture capital exits. In Mainland China, capital gains are treated as ordinary income and are generally taxed at the standard 25% corporate income tax rate for resident enterprises, or a 10% withholding rate for non-resident investors.
The disparity continues with profit repatriation. Singapore operates a one-tier system with 0% withholding tax on dividends paid to non-residents, meaning tax paid at the corporate level is final. China applies a 10% withholding tax on dividends leaving the country, creating an additional layer of tax leakage for foreign parent companies.
China does offer targeted relief. Companies qualifying for High and New Technology Enterprise status receive a reduced 15% corporate tax rate, narrowing the gap with Singapore considerably. On consumption taxes, Singapore’s GST sits at 9%, while China’s standard VAT rate is 6 to 13% with multiple tiers adding compliance complexity.
For regional headquarters pooling and distributing profits across Asia, Singapore’s zero-dividend-withholding structure delivers measurable efficiency.
Intellectual Property and Dispute Resolution
Your patents, trademarks, and trade secrets need a jurisdiction that will actually protect them. Singapore delivers Asia’s strongest IP regime (virtually equal with South Korea), with enforcement mechanisms foreign rights holders can trust. China has made progress (ranked 24th globally), but retains a significant gap in IP protection – and one structural quirk catches many foreign companies completely off guard.
China’s “first-to-file” trademark system means local actors can register your brand before you do. Defensive filings should happen well before market entry, not after. Many Western firms have learned this lesson in an expensive way.
The arbitration data tells its own story. Singapore’s International Arbitration Centre handled 625 cases in 2024, with 91% being international disputes between parties from different countries. China, across 5 institutions, heard nearly 47,000 cases – a far higher volume, but heavily domestic in nature. Consequently, when multinationals face high-value cross-border conflicts, they choose Singapore. The preference reflects trust in judicial independence and enforcement certainty.
Labour and Operating Costs
China’s reputation as a low-cost manufacturing base is fading. Manufacturing wages have risen approximately 6% year-on-year, pushing labour-intensive industries toward cheaper markets elsewhere in Southeast Asia. Singapore sits at the opposite end of the spectrum – real wages grew 3.2% in 2024, and the city-state’s cost of living runs 33% higher than Shanghai.
The talent picture adds complexity. 62% of organisations across Asia faced moderate to extreme skill shortages in 2024. Singapore struggles to fill specialised AI and cybersecurity roles domestically. China has the opposite problem: youth unemployment at 16.9% means an abundant pool of junior talent, but fierce competition for senior technical staff.
Real estate flips the cost equation entirely. China’s office market favours tenants, with vacancy rates at 23.5% and rents falling 2.9% quarter-on-quarter. Companies planning large back-office operations or regional service centres will find significantly cheaper space in Chinese cities than in Singapore’s tight market.
Logistics and Trade Access
Moving physical goods changes the calculation considerably. Singapore holds the #1 position in the World Bank Logistics Performance Index, with customs clearance and port infrastructure that set global standards. China ranks 20th – impressive given its sheer scale, but slower on processing efficiency.
Singapore’s trade network punches well above its weight. The city-state has signed 28 free trade agreements covering 90+ economies, including the CPTPP and EU-Singapore FTA. Both nations participate in RCEP, giving either location preferential market access across the Asia-Pacific region. For transhipment and broader regional distribution, Singapore remains the default choice.
Comparison at a Glance
Based on the points above, we have prepared a table for your easy reference:
| Aspect | Singapore | China |
|---|---|---|
| Company Formation |
|
|
| Tax Structure |
|
|
| IP |
|
|
| Labour and Overheads |
|
|
| Logistics and Trade |
|
|
Where to Next With InCorp
FAQs about Holding Company in Singapore?
How long does it take to register a company in Singapore versus China?
- Singapore registration takes 1 to 2 days. China usually requires 2 to 4 weeks for the same process. Singapore uses a digitised system that speeds up setup for foreign investors. China demands more paperwork and administrative investment from the start.
How does intellectual property protection compare between the two jurisdictions?
- Singapore has the strongest IP system in Asia. China is improving yet uses a "first-to-file" rule. This means others can register your trademark if you do not file first. We recommend defensive filings in China before you enter the market.
Do I need a local partner to start a business in Singapore or China?
- Foreigners can own 100% of a Singapore company without local partners. You must have one resident director. China allows full foreign ownership yet limits activities to a specific Business Scope. You can only perform activities printed on your business licence.
Get valuable advice before you start your business!
About the Author
